New York’s Rape Loophole Still Hasn’t Closed
![]() November 17, 2026 Salutations, Meteor readers, Raise your hand if you cannot get the read of the century out of your head. ![]() In today’s newsletter, we dig into New York State’s inability to eliminate its “voluntary intoxication exclusion” loophole. Plus, the truth behind “Sister” and some much-needed justice for teen girls. Googling “mews house”, Shannon Melero ![]() The Loophole That Refuses to CloseInside New York’s continued failure of survivorsBY SHANNON MELERO In the weeks after Jane Doe filed her lawsuit against Cornell University, the media and an angry public fixated on New York’s voluntary intoxication exclusion loophole—a legal statute that fails to criminalize rape if the victim was drunk of their own volition. Americans wondered how such a glaring gap in the penal code could go unaddressed for so long. (Nearly every iteration of this bill has had unanimous support in the state Senate, passing six times, yet Speaker Carl Heastie has never brought it to a vote since it was first proposed eight years ago.) There were calls for Governor Kathy Hochul and the New York State Assembly to do something, anything, about this. Heastie formed a working group to review this issue, but nothing tangible has come of it. The question remains: What’s the holdup?Some of the discussions behind the scenes provide a glimpse into just how difficult it’s been to close this loophole. In October the women’s caucus of the legislature invited Claire McCue, a psychotherapist who specializes in gender-based violence, to conduct a Zoom training for them on trauma and how legislation can better support survivors, as part of a larger meeting involving updates about the legislation. During the Q&A, McCue recalls, one of the lawmakers mentioned a “concern [about] whether or not women lie about their assault[s].” The lawmaker referenced the infamous 2007 Duke case in which a young woman falsely accused three students of sexual assault and asked McCue to explain why this happens. Caught off guard, McCue says, she told the group that while false allegations do happen, they are “very, very rare.” McCue reminded the women’s caucus that a fear of false reports “shouldn’t dominate our attention” when it comes to legislation. “This [question] was very revealing of what survivors face when they come forward,” she says now. “The fear that nobody will believe them. And when I’m asked questions like that, it really affirms where that fear comes from.” ![]() NEW YORK STATE SENATOR NATHALIA FERNANDEZ (R) AT A PRESS CONFERENCE WITH MEMBERS OF THE JUSTICE WITHOUT EXCLUSION COALITION, SHORTLY AFTER THE JANE DOE LAWSUIT WAS ANNOUNCED. (PHOTO BY SALEEN SALEH) The “due process” argumentLawmakers’ hesitations go beyond the specter of false allegations. They’re also worried that the language of the bill is too vague and could turn all drunk sex into a crime—a private concern that became public in September when Assemblymember Patrick Burke of Buffalo was heard referring to the bill as the “ruining drunk-sex-bill,” a title he claims was used by others in the assembly as a shorthand. And one of the most common objections from legislators is how this bill could impact Black and brown men. A spokesperson from the office of Assemblymember Emily Gallagher, who declined to be a co-sponsor of the bill, said the language was “overly broad in a way likely to cause unintended consequences…[for] the people who are already most marginalized in our criminal legal system–young men of color and anyone who can’t afford a good lawyer.” Gallagher is now a member of Heastie’s working group. However, advocates who have spoken with Gallagher and other members of the assembly claim that legislators have been told, repeatedly, that there isn’t any evidence to support this concern. Minister Peace, an advocate for the legislation to fix the loophole and a member of the NAACP Brooklyn Branch Justice Reform Committee, urges anyone to look at the numbers. “[Assembly members argue] that this bill is going to have Black and brown kids thrown in jail left and right, but if that were the case, we would have seen it in New York already,” he tells The Meteor. He points to other survivor-focused legislation like 2015’s Enough is Enough, which required colleges to have stronger policies on college campuses. If there had been an uptick in arrests against young men of color, Peace argues, “we would have empirical evidence.” According to NYPD data, between 2015 and 2025, there has actually been a dip in the percentage of rape suspects who are Black or Hispanic, from 51 percent to 46 percent. In states where similar loopholes have been closed, like Minnesota and Texas, the numbers show that the majority of people arrested for sexual assault are white, and there have been no known surges in arrests of men of color on sexual assault charges. (Also, “Minnesota took on their loophole within three months of it getting national attention,” Peace says.) ![]() MEMBERS OF THE JUSTICE WITHOUT EXCLUSION COALITION OUTSIDE OF CARL HEASTIE’S OFFICE IN THE BRONX. (PHOTO BY SALEEN SALEH) Straw men versus human survivorsThese arguments against the bill primarily center around hypothetical men being caught in a bad situation—at the expense of very real survivors. “What’s really important here is for survivors to feel whole, and to feel that they have closure,” says Elisa Batista, the campaign director of the national advocacy organization UltraViolet. “[They] are purposefully ignoring the needs of Black and brown survivors” by not bringing this bill to the floor for a vote, Batista says. No one understands what it is to be ignored in that way better than Lavinia Masters, a Texas-based advocate who helped pass the Lavinia Masters Act in that state after the rape kit from her attack sat untouched on a shelf for more than 20 years. “We cannot discuss protecting communities of color from potential injustices within the criminal justice system without also acknowledging the sexual violence, disparities in reporting, and barriers to justice experienced by survivors within those same communities,” she says. Masters, who has spoken to members of the NYS Assembly about other pieces of survivor legislation, was present at a caucus meeting in 2024 where multiple sources told The Meteor that Assemblymember Latrice Walker said that there are more serious crimes than rape. “The impression [her comment] left on me was that the seriousness of sexual assault was being minimized,” says Masters. “That was deeply concerning.” Walker, who has vocally opposed the bill, is also now a member of Heastie’s working group. (Walker did not reply to a question about her comment at the caucus meeting, but when asked about her opposition to the bill, Walker’s office sent a statement to The Meteor that read in part, “Any criticism of my intentions is wrongheaded. And as a sexual assault survivor, I need no lectures.”) The man who could change it allAbove all the concerns slowing this bill down, there still remains the immovable force that is Speaker Carl Heastie, who is reluctant to adequately explain his own stonewalling. Heastie claimed in a recent interview on The Brian Lehrer Show that he only brings bills to a vote when he’s certain they can pass; he believes he needs at least 80 votes to feel comfortable. However, in 2025, he had those votes and his preferred amended language to preserve due process, Peace says. There was still no vote. So advocates, legislators, and this beleaguered reporter are grasping at straws to explain what’s taking so long. Is there money involved? Are there skeletons in various closets since, as Batista notes, “sexual abuse is rampant in politics”? Or is this genuinely about strengthening due process in a penal code that already heavily favors perpetrators of sexual assault at the expense of their victims? That, Masters says, is a false conundrum. “We do not have to choose between protecting survivors and protecting due process,” Masters says. “We have a responsibility to pursue both.” AND:
![]() FOLLOW THE METEOR Thank you for reading The Meteor! Got this from a friend?
|
![]()







