“The Man I Knew Couldn’t Have Just Disappeared”
She was dating a guy who swore he was a feminist—until he went down the rabbit hole of misogyny. 20-year-old Liz tells her story to Nona Willis Aronowitz.
We met at a feminist book club. It was a group organized through my school, and the book was Simone de Beauvoir’s The Second Sex. I wasn’t impressed by him at all at first, because he was the only guy and wasn’t contributing much to the conversation. I was like, “What’s a man doing here?”
But eventually we started talking outside the group, and I was pretty charmed by him and how he expressed himself. We went to the same college in the Netherlands. He is American from a conservative family; I am Dutch. I was about to turn 17 and he was a little older, like 19 or 20. He was really thoughtful, intelligent, and interested in what I had to say. We could talk for hours about pretty much anything. He was generous and kind. He had a great relationship with his mother and his sister. I just felt so comfortable with him in a way I hadn’t felt before. He was more moderate than me on certain issues…things like immigration or capitalism. But when it came to women’s rights, we were in agreement. I found it very important to be with someone who had the same feminist beliefs as me, and I thought I had found him.
Before, he’d encourage me to speak my mind, but now he was talking over me. He was saying things like, “You were born to be a mother.”
Then in 2023, a little less than a year after we started dating, he dropped out of school because it didn’t end up being what he wanted. It wasn’t a dealbreaker at first. He was still very proud of my ambition and he encouraged my aspirations, but him dropping out ended up being the thing that started showing the cracks. It wasn’t a dramatic shift; it was gradual. He started pushing away everything that was more intellectual. He started to doubt research. He only had a part-time job so he started playing video games a lot and going to the gym. He joined a bunch of online gym groups, and eventually he was watching people like Jordan Peterson and Andrew Tate.
At first he had some distance from it; he said he just wanted to see the other side and keep an open mind. Then he started to say things like, “Well, [Tate] does have some good points. Going to the gym and taking care of yourself is good.” He also started making jokes about how nice it would be if I stayed at home, if I were a stay-at-home mother, even though we’d talked about how neither of us wanted kids. And then when I questioned him, he would say that it was just a joke.

His attitude towards me started slowly changing. Before, he’d encourage me to speak my mind, but now he was talking over me. I started having to defend things about myself that I never had to defend before, like wanting to go to school, not wanting to have kids. He was saying things like, “You’re meant to be a mother. You were born to be a mother.”
Our conversations became arguments and they started becoming more demeaning in nature. He became aggressive whenever we disagreed, as if I was personally harming him by not having the same opinion as him. He started steamrolling me, taking what I’m saying out of context, and making insults and generalizations. He would say things like, “All you care about is portraying some sort of agenda.” Whenever I did something he didn’t like, it would be an example of the “problem with women today,” or he would say that my education made me think I was an expert on everything.
Earlier this year, I had a medical emergency and I spent several weeks in the hospital. He never came to visit me, not once.
It took me quite a while to truly see what was happening, because I was still convinced that I knew him; that man I knew couldn’t have just disappeared. And at first it was hard to actually pinpoint, because it was just so subtle. This kind of thinking is becoming a little more popular in the Netherlands—we live on the outskirts of the city where the far right is more present, and the Netherlands had quite a right-wing government just a year ago—but he didn’t voice these views as much in the outside world as he did to me. In a way, it feels like he was aware that it wasn’t publicly accepted.
I kept staying and staying, hoping to be able to change him and help him, until eventually something happened that made it quite clear that he did not care about me more than he cared about a rock in his shoe.
Earlier this year, I had a medical emergency and I spent several weeks in the hospital. He never came to visit me, not once. When we finally did talk again, his explanation was that women shouldn’t be taken care of by men; it should be the other way around. Also, my medical emergency made it so that pregnancy would be more complicated. I think after he made the connection that it would be much harder to have children with me, it was like his interest was gone.
Our breakup ended up being quite mutual; it was obvious that he did not really see me as a partner anymore. I told him pretty clearly, “I’ve been telling you the whole time that I don’t want kids, and I’m definitely not going to have them now when it’s a risk to my own life and my own well-being.” He became very aggressive, this time physically. He was grabbing me and shaking me, as if he were trying to physically put his words inside of me. It was obvious to me that he saw me as inferior. Our final conversation was amicable; I just didn’t want to fight. I kind of regret not speaking my mind at that moment.
The biggest thing I’ve realized from all this, with a few months of distance, is that you cannot teach someone empathy at your own expense. You can love someone, you can understand where they’re coming from, you can want them to be a better person, but you cannot do the work of developing their empathy for them. Nobody changes if they don’t want to change.
Liz, 20, lives and works in the Netherlands. Her last name is withheld for privacy reasons.
More about the manosphere:
Break Up With the Manosphere
We need a womanosphere
The Women Beneath the Men
On Louis Theroux’s manosphere documentary
The Devil Wears a Prairie Dress
On Yesteryear and tradwives
The Sinister World of Looksmaxxing
Clavicular enters the mainstream